Why Standardisation Matters
Most café reviews are useless. Not because the reviewer doesn't know coffee but because every review is measuring something different. One reviewer judges the latte art. Another focuses on the ambience. A third scores the whole menu. You end up with ratings that reflect the reviewer's mood, the table they sat at, and whether the waitstaff smiled at them.
That's not a review. That's a vibe check.
The only way to compare 600 cafés honestly is to hold every variable constant except the coffee itself. Same drinks. Same order. Same methodology. Every time. That's what Koffee Review does.
The Two Drinks. Every Time.
At every café we visit, we order exactly two things:
One Latte · One Double Shot Espresso
That's it. We don't order the batch brew. We don't try the pour over. We don't ask what they're proud of. We order the same two drinks we ordered at the last place and the place before that.
Why these two? Because they're the most ordered drinks in Australian cafés. The latte tests the balance of milk and espresso which is the most technically demanding skill for a barista. The double shot espresso reveals the coffee in its purest form meaning the bean, the grind, the extraction. Together they tell you almost everything you need to know about whether a café can make coffee.
If a café can't execute these two drinks, it can't execute anything.
The Scoring System
Every café gets a single score out of 10, based purely on the taste we personally enjoy. No technical rubric. No judging panel. Just whether the coffee is good.
| SCORE | VERDICT | WHAT IT MEANS |
|---|---|---|
| Below 3.9 | AVOID | Not coffee. An offence. |
| 4.0 to 4.9 | NOT FOR US | We won't finish it. |
| 5.1 to 5.4 | JUST OKAY | Drinkable. Forgettable. |
| 5.5 to 5.9 | AVERAGE | Average cup. Not memorable. |
| 6.1 to 6.4 | TAKE OR LEAVE | If we're around, maybe. Won't travel for it. |
| 6.5 to 6.9 | DECENT | Good enough. Not exciting. |
| 7.1 to 7.4 | SOLID | Consistently good. Worth a visit. |
| 7.5 to 7.9 | LOVED | We'd travel up to 5km just for this again. |
| 8.1 to 8.9 | GREAT 👑 | Top tier. Sits on the king seat. |
| 9.1 to 9.9 | ELITE | Rare level. We'll go anywhere for this, any time. |
A 5.0 is not an insult. It means exactly what it says. Most cafés in Australia are average. A 5.0 is just being honest about that.
We Don't Overhype
We score coffee purely on taste we personally enjoy. That's it. Not the playlist. Not the interior design. Not the latte art or the origin story on the menu. Not whether the barista was chatty or the café was fully booked on a Sunday.
We don't care if the fit-out cost half a million dollars. We don't care if the bean is single origin or from a small batch farm with a certified B Corp status. We don't care if the café has a five star Google rating.
We care about what's in the cup.
What We're Not Judging
The 7.5+ Sticker
THE KOFFEE REVIEW STAMP
Cafés that score 7.5 or above earn the Koffee Review stamp of approval. This cannot be applied for. It cannot be purchased. It is given when the coffee earns it and not before.
A score on a screen fades. A sticker on a window stays.
Why We Never Change the Order
We get asked this a lot. Did you try the filter coffee? Their batch brew is better. You should have ordered the single origin.
We understand. But the moment we start ordering different things at different cafés, the comparisons become meaningless. The cafés that score well on our system are cafés that have their fundamentals right. Get the latte and the espresso right and you can offer anything else on the menu with confidence.
"We order the same thing every time.
One latte. One double shot espresso. One score.
No BS."
600+ cups in. Still chasing that perfect 10.
BROWSE ALL CAFÉ REVIEWS
Looking for the best coffee in Brisbane? See our full Brisbane guide →